📚 Reader Reviews
H.S.★★★★★Vol 1
Oh man, I love this girl!
After being expelled for assaulting a teacher at her Catholic school, Maria Kawai transfers to a public school that is also her last chance. Once there she runs into the same problem as at her old school with people misunderstanding her blunt tone for cruelness, thus leading the majority of the class to tease and taunt her, to the point even her own teacher automatically assumes Maria is always at fault. But the class king and bad boy are drawn to Maria and help her to make friends, be understood, and see the world with a lovely spin.
With this first volume I have to say, I absolutely love Maria! Her bluntness and awkward social skills remind me a bit of myself. What people mistake as cold and uncaring is actually Maria seeing through to their hearts and speaking out the ugly truth that they're hiding, from even themselves sometimes. That may sound rough on the surface, however I believe she does it as a way of protecting people from others harsh feelings, without realizing that is actually hurting the very people she is trying to protect.
The art is very pretty, it's classic shojo with sketchy sleek lines, and while most of the characters match said style, Maria has notably bigger eyes and drawn in more of moe style art.
This is a definite series for any romance fan to try out. I am really looking forward to seeing where the series goes, and I definitely want to see Maria end up with a certain bad boy.
Check out my bookstagram! @Witchy.Otaku
H.S.★★★★★Vol 5
I am loving this series!
As Maria's feelings for Shin start bubbling closer to the surface, Maria gets reunited with a former friend from her old school whose intentions for coming back into Maria's life are sketchy at best. Chaos inducing and heart breaking at worse.
I'm not one to pay close attention to tropes or genres, I like what I like, but high school love triangles are a bit done in my opinion. They're not necessarily a bad thing, they're so popular cause they do work and they are entertaining, however it is better when the triangle shifts into different shapes such as a square, or cube if you will.
I hope in this case it's more like a circle within the middle of an S, so the main couple stays together. Poor Yusuke, the boy is a total simp/manic-pixie-dream-boy, I wish he would gain more self-worth to see himself more than a helper.
And I wish Tomoyo and Ayu got more page time, I think it would be fun peeking into their lives a bit more.
I can't wait to read on!
Check out my bookstagram! @Witchy.Otaku
H.S.★★★★★Vol 10
No... No!!
I am huffing right now. For the past 2 volumes things have been getting more dramatic in odd ways, but ways that are on theme for the story and characters. However, this time, this volume has taken too far, and I will not stand for it! I believe that blame should not be assigned unless that is the only way to see how to fix the problem, I am feeling feelings at the moment of writing this and I don't care, I blame the editor, Ms. K. Dead stop.
Now I will explain how; during this volume, Maria finally lets her feelings out and recall's memories of her troubling past, and the person who reveals their feelings to her, (I'm not saying who as to not spoil anything,) practically assaults her and gropes her even though that is completely out of his character right after she gets emotional and says it she wants to "give him something." Nowhere through the rest of the series has that particular lust came out so strongly nor so surprisingly. (Well, when Shintaro, aka Eros, came into the picture he was just as blunt as Maria was in the beginning, so he said something shocking, but he didn't mean anything by it.)
So why I am assigning blame to Ms. K is because Mr. O, the first editor for the series, left sometime around the end of volume 6, I am guessing on the timeline though as his departure was announced in volume 8, and in the afterward it said that while Ms. Kay is a very lovely lady who would bring pastry, she is also ruthless in her notes and said that parts needed to be more dramatic, and it seemed like around that volume things did become more dramatic, and even Maria seemed less like Maria. Not just because she was maturing as a person, something else felt different.
While my love of the characters and Maria has not waned, I do hope that the story comes a bit more back to its roots and shows our favorite heroine and her friends in a lovelier light.
Did I use this review to vent? Yes, yes I did.
Is that unusual for me? Yes, indeed it is. …
H.S.★★★★★Vol 13
"She is the most beautiful devil."
4.5* stars
Six months after Shin's departure, Maria and company are making plans for their future as they venture into their senior year. Everyone has ideas or knows where they want to go in their life, but Maria is unsure where to go with her future. An unexpected visitor sets Maria on a path that everyone else saw coming, but devils need to find their own way to their dreams.
While I'm sad the series has come to an end, I believe this is a good ending for the characters, albeit everything was tied up a bit suddenly and cleanly to me. There was a 6 month time jump in the beginning, which is probably why things seemed sudden, however things with Maria's biological father and her grandparents, (mother side,) all seemed too perfect.
Within the past 2 volumes everything fell into place just like that, the grandparents forgiving the man who assaulted their daughter (Anna, Maria's mom) when she was 14, was forgiven just because he couldn't sing Amazing Grace, cares deeply for Maria, and fell in love with their daughter while corresponding with her by letters. Shintaro being the foster son to said man, (who has turned his life around,) was one thing, but the sudden and utter forgiveness of the grandparents felt too unrealistic. Although it was kind of nice to see people forgive one another at face value, it was still a bit much.
I like that in this volume a couple of the chapters were in other characters point of view, especially the final chapter being in Yusuke's point of view, I feel like he was the best person to describe the ending and what it meant to Maria and the others. And while I did like all the characters, I do wish that more chapters centered around Ayu and Tomoyo instead of centering around the boys so much of the time. …
Shared by readers using the My Manga Emporium app.